Fellow Stagg EKG Pro vs Timemore Fish Smart Electric

Fellow Stagg EKG Pro
Fellow
Stagg EKG Pro
$199 Upper-Mid
Check price
vs
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Timemore
Fish Smart Electric
$129 Mid-Range
Check price
Head-to-head scoreboard
Stagg EKG Pro · 2 3 TIES 2 · Fish Smart Electric
The verdict

The Timemore Fish Smart at $129 matches the EKG Pro on core brewing features for $70 less. Buy the EKG Pro only if Bluetooth scheduling or the Fellow brand is important to you.

Spec face-off

Bars scaled to the higher value. Coloured = wins that spec.

Stagg EKG Pro
Fish Smart Electric
0.9 L
Capacity
0.8 L
1,200 W
Power
1,000 W
1.1 kg
Weight
0.95 kg

Full specifications

Spec
Stagg EKG Pro
Fish Smart Electric
Price
$199
$129
Capacity
0.9 L
0.8 L
Power
1,200 W
1,000 W
Weight
1.1 kg
0.95 kg
Temp Control
Yes
Yes
Hold Temp
Yes
Yes
Gooseneck
Yes
Yes
Display
LCD
LCD
Bluetooth
Yes

Strengths & weaknesses

Fellow Stagg EKG Pro
Fellow Stagg EKG Pro
Strengths
Bluetooth + Fellow app allows saving named temperature profiles with specific hold times
LCD display shows real-time temperature in 1°C increments versus the EKG's 5°C analog dial
Same counterbalanced handle and 3-4mm precision spout as the base EKG
Trade-offs
$20 premium over the EKG for connectivity that most users engage with actively only in the first few weeks before defaulting to a regular temperature setting
Bluetooth range of approximately 3 meters requires proximity to the kettle for app control
Fellow app requires Bluetooth re-pairing on each session (no persistent connection)
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Strengths
Real-time temperature display during heating in 1°C increments
60-minute temperature hold at ±1°C
0.8L compact body is the smallest footprint of any electric gooseneck in this list
Trade-offs
0.8L is the smallest capacity in this list
1000W heating element is the least powerful in this list
After-sales service in North America is limited

Full comparison

The Timemore Fish Smart at $129 and the Fellow Stagg EKG Pro at $199 are both gooseneck electric kettles with LCD displays and temperature hold. The Timemore is $70 cheaper, 0.15kg lighter, and holds 0.8L versus the Pro's 0.9L. For the actual task of heating water to a precise temperature and holding it, both perform equally well.

The EKG Pro's key differentiators are Bluetooth connectivity and app control. These allow you to schedule preheat times, set timers, and monitor temperature remotely. If you want your kettle at 205°F when you wake up, the EKG Pro can do that. The Timemore cannot.

Timemore's build quality is genuinely impressive at the price point. The Fish Smart's gooseneck produces a controlled, consistent pour comparable to the EKG Pro's. Its LCD display is clean and responsive. This isn't a case of a budget product cutting obvious corners.

For brewers who don't need Bluetooth, the Timemore Fish Smart is the clear winner on value at $70 less. For brewers who want app scheduling and are invested in a premium brand experience, the EKG Pro earns its premium.

More kettles matchups