Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck vs Timemore Fish Smart Electric
The Timemore Fish Smart costs $1 more than the Bonavita but adds temperature hold, making it the better buy for almost everyone. The Bonavita is only worth considering if you always brew immediately after heating.
Spec face-off
Bars scaled to the higher value. Coloured = wins that spec.
Full specifications
Full comparison
The Bonavita BV382510V at $130 and the Timemore Fish Smart at $129 are nearly the same price, which makes this comparison straightforward. The Timemore offers temperature hold, an LCD display, and a lighter 0.95kg body. The Bonavita offers no temperature hold, an LED display, and a 1.0L capacity versus the Timemore's 0.8L.
Temperature hold is the decisive factor. The Bonavita will heat to your target, but once there, it does not maintain the temperature. The Timemore holds your target for 60 minutes. For $1 more, that's a significant functional advantage.
The Bonavita's 200ml capacity advantage is its only practical edge over the Timemore. If you regularly brew full 1.0L batches or brew for multiple people without refilling, the Bonavita's extra capacity has value. For most single-cup brewers, 0.8L is sufficient.
At effectively the same price, the Timemore Fish Smart is the better kettle. Its temperature hold, lighter weight, and clean LCD display make it the more capable tool. Buy the Bonavita only if the 200ml extra capacity is genuinely important to your workflow.