Compare

Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck vs Timemore Fish Smart Electric

Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
Bonavita
BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
$130 Entry
Check price
vs
Winner
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Timemore
Fish Smart Electric
$129 Mid-Range
Check price
Head-to-head scoreboard
BV382510V Variable Gooseneck · 1 3 TIES 3 · Fish Smart Electric
The verdict

The Timemore Fish Smart costs $1 more than the Bonavita but adds temperature hold, making it the better buy for almost everyone. The Bonavita is only worth considering if you always brew immediately after heating.

Which should you buy?

Match the row to your routine — the winning side is who we'd pick.

Pour-over routine: heat water, brew immediately, walk away
Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
200ml capacity advantage matters when you're brewing for two with one boil. Hold isn't relevant if you pour at temp.
Brewing slow — multiple V60s, AeroPress + pour-over combo, distracted mornings
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
60-minute hold means your last cup is the same temperature as your first. Bonavita re-heats every cycle.
Apartment kitchen, limited counter space
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
0.95kg vs 1.0kg, and the Fish's narrower base footprint fits behind a sink. Bonavita is wider.
Multi-cup batch brewing for guests or large french press
Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
1L capacity finishes a 8-cup french press without refilling. Fish's 0.8L needs a top-up.
Prefer LCD over LED for current-temp visibility at a glance
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Fish's LCD shows target and current temp simultaneously. Bonavita's LED shows target only.
Tea drinker — need 70°C for green tea, hold for the steep
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Hold mode is the tea-brewing feature. Bonavita's lack of hold makes it a coffee-only kettle.

Spec face-off

Bars scaled to the higher value. Coloured = wins that spec.

BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
Fish Smart Electric
1 L
Capacity
0.8 L
1,000 W
Power
1,000 W
1 kg
Weight
0.95 kg

Full specifications

Spec
BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
Fish Smart Electric
Price
$130
$129
Capacity
1 L
0.8 L
Power
1,000 W
1,000 W
Weight
1 kg
0.95 kg
Temp Control
Yes
Yes
Hold Temp
No
Yes
Gooseneck
Yes
Yes
Display
LED
LCD

Strengths & weaknesses

Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
Strengths
Variable temperature in 1°C increments from 60-100°C
1.0L capacity serves full Chemex or multi-cup V60 sessions without mid-brew refilling
Gooseneck spout enables pour-over flow control
Trade-offs
No temperature hold function
LED display reads in steps rather than showing real-time temperature during heating
Plastic-heavy handle feels less precise during slow controlled pours compared to metal-handled competition
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Strengths
Real-time temperature display during heating in 1°C increments
60-minute temperature hold at ±1°C
0.8L compact body is the smallest footprint of any electric gooseneck in this list
Trade-offs
0.8L is the smallest capacity in this list
1000W heating element is the least powerful in this list
After-sales service in North America is limited

Full comparison

The Bonavita BV382510V at $130 and the Timemore Fish Smart at $129 are nearly the same price, which makes this comparison straightforward. The Timemore offers temperature hold, an LCD display, and a lighter 0.95kg body. The Bonavita offers no temperature hold, an LED display, and a 1.0L capacity versus the Timemore's 0.8L.

Temperature hold is the decisive factor. The Bonavita will heat to your target, but once there, it does not maintain the temperature. The Timemore holds your target for 60 minutes. For $1 more, that's a significant functional advantage.

The Bonavita's 200ml capacity advantage is its only practical edge over the Timemore. If you regularly brew full 1.0L batches or brew for multiple people without refilling, the Bonavita's extra capacity has value. For most single-cup brewers, 0.8L is sufficient.

At effectively the same price, the Timemore Fish Smart is the better kettle. Its temperature hold, lighter weight, and clean LCD display make it the more capable tool. Buy the Bonavita only if the 200ml extra capacity is genuinely important to your workflow.

What owners actually report

Paraphrased from long-running owner threads and review write-ups.

Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
Bonavita BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
What owners praise
Gooseneck pour is well-balanced — consistent stream control without wrist fatigue at low flow rates.
1L capacity handles batch brewing without a mid-pour refill, which the smaller Timemore can't match.
Common complaints
No temperature hold is the recurring complaint — once boiled, the water cools at ~1°C per minute. Distracted brewers reheat.
LED display only shows target temp, not current temp — you don't know when it's ready unless you watch the climb.
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
Timemore Fish Smart Electric
What owners praise
Temperature hold is the feature — 60 minutes at target means consistent pour-over temps across multiple cups.
LCD display shows target AND current temp — you know exactly when it's ready, no guessing.
Common complaints
0.8L capacity caps your batch brew options; french press 8-cup needs a refill mid-process.
Hold mode uses ~10W continuously — not a meaningful electricity cost, but the kettle stays warm to the touch.

Accessory & upgrade compatibility

Category
BV382510V Variable Gooseneck
Fish Smart Electric
Temperature control
Variable to 100°C; reheats but does not hold
Variable to 100°C; holds target for 60 minutes
Capacity
1.0L — supports multi-cup and large french press batches
0.8L — sufficient for one-to-two cup pour-over
Display
LED — shows target temp only
LCD — shows target and current temp
Power
1000W — reaches boil in ~4 minutes from cold
1000W — same boil time; hold mode adds ~10W to maintain temperature
Gooseneck shape
Tapered narrow spout — slow controllable pour
Tapered narrow spout — comparable pour control

Should you buy neither? Two alternatives

Fellow Stagg EKG
Fellow Stagg EKG
$179

$165 — the design-forward kettle with hold mode and LCD. Costs $35 more than the Fish but adds the Stagg's design pedigree.

Check price
Brewista Artisan Variable Gooseneck
Brewista Artisan Variable Gooseneck
$160

$150 — variable temp, hold, and the most refined gooseneck pour control in this price class. Worth the upcharge for daily pour-over.

Check price

Frequently asked questions

What's the actual difference between these kettles for daily pour-over?

Hold mode. If you brew one cup and pour immediately, they're equivalent. If you brew slowly, set up a chemex, and return to a half-pour later — the Timemore's hold keeps your water at target.

Is 1L worth giving up hold mode for?

Only if you regularly brew for 4+ people or use a large french press. For one-to-two-cup pour-over, the 0.8L Timemore is plenty.

Can either kettle hit 70°C for green tea?

Yes — both have variable temperature in 1°C increments. Only the Timemore holds 70°C through a 4-minute steep without reheating.

Is the LCD really that much better than the LED?

It's the difference between 'is it ready yet?' and 'I can see exactly when'. Small thing, but you interact with it every brew.

Are these kettles loud during heat-up?

Both are quiet — gooseneck kettles have small heating elements and don't make rolling-boil noise. Click of the click-off lever is the loudest moment.

More kettles matchups

BV382510V Variable Gooseneck vs
Fellow Stagg EKG
$179
BV382510V Variable Gooseneck vs
Fellow Stagg EKG Pro
$199
BV382510V Variable Gooseneck vs
Brewista Artisan Variable Gooseneck
$160
BV382510V Variable Gooseneck vs
Hario V60 Buono Drip Kettle
$59